Bette
Midler Sings The Rosemary Clooney Songbook
(Sept 30, 2003)
US:
Gold
Billboard peak: # 14
Tracks: "You'll Never Know" - "This Ole House"
-
"On A Slow Boat To China" (with Barry Manilow) - "Hey
There" - "Tenderly" -
"Come On-A My House" - "Mambo Italiano"
- "Sisters" (with Linda Ronstadt) -
"Memories Of You" - "In The Cool, Cool, Cool
Of The Evening" -
"White Christmas"
Listen
To Audio Samples
Seattle
Gay News
Oct. 10, 2003
It
makes perfect sense for Bette Midler to immerse her divine self
into a catalog of songs by the late, great Rosemary Clooney. She's
essentially one of her followers. With the help of old friend Barry
Manilow, who produced her first two breakthrough albums, Midler
settles right into a
string of the Girl Singer's hits, all originally recorded in the
1950's.
Midler's
perky persona makes a delightful presence on the sprightly "Come
On-A My House" and the zesty "Mambo Italiano," which
features a high-kicking arrangement by Manilow and Robbie Buchanan,
who also serve as co-producers for this fine, timely tribute. When
she isn't getting
cheeky with Manilow, as in the Bing Crosby/Clooney bopper "On
a Slow Boat to China," she's singing shoulder to shoulder with
Linda Ronstadt on "Sisters." The album's finest moments
are Midler's down-home, bluegrassy version of "This Ole House"
and her glistening touch to
Crosby's nostalgic "White Christmas," which Clooney repolished
in 1954.
Bette
Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook is a soaring success
in two ways. First, it provides a glorious avenue for Midler to
strut her pop-to-showtunes vocal expertise. And second, it packs
in plenty of va-va voom in an homage to a singer who put style and
class on an out-of-reach shelf. Given the chance to do a legend
justice, Midler simply marvels.
Tower.com
10/13/03
Recorded
at Sony Music Studios, Culver City, California; The Hop, Studio
City, California; Schnee Studios, North Hollywood, California. Includes
liner notes by Bette Midler, Barry Manilow.
Bette
Midler occupies a unique place in the world of pop vocalists; she's
recorded in so many styles (blowsy rockers, glossy pop ballads,
intimate cabaret) that she's impossible to pigeonhole. So it's not
such a shock to find her reaching back to an earlier era of pop
singing for THE ROSEMARY CLOONEY SONGBOOK. In paying tribute to
her beloved Clooney, Midler engages the services of none other than
MOR icon Barry Manilow as arranger, a role he played for her before
embarking on his solo career. This is far from a by-the-numbers
stroll through the Clooney catalog, though. Midler and Manilow dip
into smooth jazz ("Come On-A My House"), boogie-woogie
("On a Slow Boat to China"), Americana ("This Ole
House"), and orchestrated jazz ("Hey There") among
other modes, introducing these Clooney-associated tunes to a whole
new generation.
Orlando
Sentinel
Published October 3, 2003
Columnist Commander Coconut
Come
on-a give-a listen
I haven't
bought a new Bette Midler album in a while. The first ones were
much the best, still fun to listen to after all these years, especially
anything live (Live at Last in 1977, Mud Will Be Flung Tonight in
1985).
But
I like her new CD, Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook.
Bette
and her producer, Barry Manilow, were on Today Wednesday talking
up the CD and performing -- doing two of the best cuts from the
album, "Come On-a My House" and "On a Slow Boat to
China" (they might have done more, but I didn't watch Today's
third hour).
"Slow
Boat," by the way, has this fun couplet: "Out on the briny/
Where the moon's big and shiny."
Two
of the album's cuts don't work ("Hey There," "This
Ole House"), but it's interesting that two others, better others,
are songs that Clooney had said she didn't much care for: "Come
On-a My House" and "Mambo Italiano."
Midler
has always liked songs, usually more obscure ones, that have tricky
or eccentric lyrics, so both "House" and "Mambo"
fit that bill as does "In the Cool, Cool, Cool of the Evening."
Both
Midler and Manilow had known Clooney for years. Manilow, who said
he was thrilled when Clooney recorded "When October Goes,"
a Johnny Mercer lyric that he set to music, came up with the idea
of the tribute album and got in touch with Midler. The two first
hooked up when he was her pianist at her famous and infamous gig
at the Continental Baths in New York. Later, famously, they had
something of a falling-out, but both said they had a fine time doing
the Clooney album.
Another
of Clooney's good singer friends was Linda Ronstadt; she and Midler
duet on "Sisters," the Irving Berlin song Rosemary sang
in the movie White Christmas.
The
album begins and ends with beautiful ballads: "You'll Never
Know" and "White Christmas."
AMG
Matt Collar
Cabaret
icon Bette Midler reunites with her old piano partner Barry Manilow
for the first time in over 30 years to toast one of their mutual
idols on Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook. Clooney
was one of the top jazz/pop vocalists of the '50s whose clear, bright
tone, impeccable melodicism, and smiling, girl-next-door image came
together to make classics out of tunes like "In the Cool, Cool,
Cool of the Evening" and "Hey There" — both covered
here. In that tradition, Midler's plucky blonde persona and genre-crossing
style and Manilow's modern day blend of Mercer and Porter make this
album work — most of the time. Mostly what you get is the Divine
Miss M and "Mister Manila," as Midler affectionately refers
to Manilow, returning to their '70s New York roots on "On a
Slow Boat to China," a solid and classy version of "Sisters"
with Linda Ronstadt taking the Betty Clooney role, and a very Dixie
Chicks-esque contemporary bluegrass reworking of "This Ole
House." Least of all, you get limp, hip-hop-lite arrangements
of "Come On-A My House" and "Mambo Italiano,"
which only serve to drain the songs of any swing and makes the twee-period
lyrics all the more cloying. Nonetheless, Midler — who can carry
a tune on personality alone — sounds elegant and alive here and
Manilow's classy orchestral arrangements frame the proceedings with
the urbane glow of nostalgia for a time — be it the '50s or the
'70s — when a big band, a great song, and blonde with a nice voice
were all you needed for a good time. — Matt Collar
Washington
Times
Rosie, Bette's way
By T.L. Ponick
Rosemary
Clooney, who lost her life to lung cancer in 2002 at age 74, was
proof positive that America is the land of the second chance.
After
a meteoric rise to musical fame culminating in her appearance with
Bing Crosby in 1954's hit film "White Christmas," the
blond, fresh-faced girl singer from Kentucky made a string of hit
recordings and married film star Jose Ferrer seemingly out of the
blue. Hardly pausing for breath, she cranked out five babies in
short order and also landed her own TV show, but her personal wheel
of fortune took an abrupt downward spin in the 1960s.
With
her marriage on the rocks, the demanding pressures of TV, movie,
radio, and recording appearances soon drove her to an overdependence
on tranquilizers and prescription drugs. The violent death of her
friend, Sen. Robert F. Kennedy, who was gunned down in a Los Angeles
hotel only a few yards away from the singer, sank her further into
a deep, clinical depression, and she retired from showbiz for years.
After
many years of therapy, and buoyed by a successful 1976 tour with
Bing Crosby — the Old Groaner's last — Miss Clooney gradually returned
to the limelight, resurrecting her career, this time as a surprisingly
successful jazz artist and song stylist. Once again she had a string
of successful recordings and CDs on the Concord label and won respect
among a new generation of fans both here and abroad.
Actress-singer-camp
diva Bette Midler now revives the first half of Miss Clooney's career
with the new CD, "Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook."
This re-imagining of Rosie's greatest hits gets a big assist from
Barry Manilow, who has vividly re-created arrangements for most
of them, giving them the right dash of contemporary panache without
obliterating their distinctive Eisenhower-era flavor.
For
those of us who grew up mainlining on 1950s TV variety shows, this
disc is a pleasant blast from the past. Each and every track was
once a bona fide hit in its day. From the sentimental "You'll
Never Know" to the still risque "Come On-a My House"
— Miss Clooney's bizarre breakthrough hit — it's surprising how
well this songbook wears. The tunes are still spiffy, and the lyrics
actually convey complex adult emotions, something lost on today's
infantilized music moguls and mavens.
Bette
Midler is no Rosemary Clooney. Her voice lacks the depth, the nuance,
the subtle shadings — indeed, the authority — of the older diva,
particularly in the disc's concluding arrangement of "White
Christmas," the greatest holiday schmaltz classic of all time.
Still,
Miss Midler is a trooper, and she clearly holds Miss Clooney in
high esteem. Drawn out, richly melodic vowels, crystalline enunciation,
hard consonants and Midwestern "r's" were all part of
the Clooney arsenal, and Miss Midler replicates these vocal characteristics
with astonishing faithfulness. It's the sustained notes that Miss
Midler has a harder time with.
Miss
Midler does a workmanlike job on classic ballads such as "Hey
There" and "Tenderly." However, she's at her best
in upbeat, jazzy novelty songs like the aforementioned "Come
On-a My House," — which retains the weird harpsichord riffs
of the original — as well as "Mambo Italiano," "This
Ole House" and the sublimely silly "Sisters," where
she gets an effective assist from Linda Ronstadt.
Miss
Midler's reverently retro CD re-creates bygone days that weren't
nearly as drab and lifeless as tendentious post-'60s social history
pretends. True Clooney aficionados will still prefer to find original
recordings of these '50s classics in second-hand racks or in new
compilations. Still, for a new generation, this album could be the
missing link to a less in-your-face, more optimistic and melodious
past — a time when lyrical adult songs and the artists who sang
them conjured up for a more innocent youth a magical sense of the
richly emotional life that would soon be theirs.
Billboard
Magazine
Originally Reviewed: October 12, 2003
BETTE
MIDLER
Album Title: Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook
Producer(s): Barry Manilow, Robbie Buchanan
Genre: POP
Label/Catalog Number: Columbia 90350
Release Date: Sept. 30
Source: Billboard Magazine
Originally Reviewed: October 12, 2003
Standards
have never been this much fun. "Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary
Clooney Songbook," a tribute to the late singer's 1951-1958
heyday, reaches far beyond the typically maudlin collection of golden
oldies, injecting humor and sarcasm into a crafty selection of chestnuts.
The production role of Midler's original arranger, Barry Manilow
(with Robbie Buchanan) is essential, with his persuasive versatility
showcased on the lush "Tenderly," the bare-bones album
opener and 1952 No. 1 "You'll Never Know" and the subtly
folky "This Ole House." But the best moment comes in Midler
and Manilow's duet "On a Slow Boat to
China" (originally recorded with Clooney and Bing Crosby),
which frolics like the good old daysClooney's and Midler/Manilow's.
Songbook" is yet another milestone album in the career of one
of pop culture's most enduring entertainers. Clooney must be swinging
from on high. CT
Christian
Science Monitor
Gregory M. Lamb
From the October 10, 2003 edition
POP/JAZZ
Rosemary
Clooney Rosemary Clooney: The Best of the Concord Years (Concord
Records) and Bette Midler Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney
Songbook (Columbia Records): Incomparable vocal stylist Rosemary
Clooney, who died last year, spent 25 years recording pop standards
at Concord Records. Its new two-CD set shows off her mature work:
a confident, warm voice that can swing or torch it up with the best.
Her sensitive renditions give songs like "How Long Has This
Been Going On" and "Stormy Weather" back to songwriters
Gershwin and Arlen.
Bette
Midler is a diva of a later era, but her tribute CD shows how easily
the Divine Miss M might have fit in with Clooney, Judy Garland,
and Dinah Shore. It's a sweet confection that melts far too fast.
Serious fans may want both, since only three songs overlap (compare
Clooney's famous originals on "Mambo Italiano," "Hey
There," and "White Christmas" with Midler's bright
covers). -
Cincinnati
Post - Oct. 1, 2003
By Nick Clooney
Midler's CD tribute to Rosie is a winner
Many
of you reading these words are friends and fans of my late sister
Rosemary. I have good news for you. The fiery singer and actress
Bette Midler was also a friend and fan of Rosemary's. She, unlike
the rest of us, was in a position to do something about that respect
and affection.
As
it happens, her one-time pianist and longtime collaborator Barry
Manilow was Rosemary's fan and friend, too.
They
have produced what I stubbornly continue to call an album which
is a salute to Rosemary and her music. It is called "Bette
Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook." It is on Columbia
Records, it is available as
of today, and it is terrific. Run, don't walk, to get it.
Bette
and Barry picked a wide range of Rosemary's songs. Obviously, they
picked some that were their personal favorites, but they did not
neglect
Rosemary's biggest hits.
Bette's
saucy treatment of "Hey There" would have had Rosemary's
full approval. And the way she approached "This Ole House"
would have made the writer of the song, Stuart Hamblen, very happy.
As I have pointed out in this corner before, Mr. Hamblen never thought
Rosemary gave it quite the
country touch he envisioned. He did, however, cash all the royalty
checks. Bette gives the folk tune its full country due.
Throughout
this fine album, Bette did Rosemary and the rest of us the great
favor of not trying to copy her. Frankly, no one can do that, anyway.
Instead,
Bette is Bette, which is quite a remarkable thing to be. The arrangements
are uniformly excellent. They evoke the originals without ever mimicking
them.
Something
surprised me. When I saw the list of songs on the label, I assumed
Bette would be most comfortable with the tempo and novelty hits.
What blindsided me was her excellent -- dare I say sweet? -- treatment
of Rosemary's trademark "Tenderly."
How
to handle the duet "Slow Boat to China" with Bing Crosby?
Just call on the talents of producer Barry Manilow.
How
to handle the duet "Sisters" with our sister Betty Clooney?
Just call on the talents of Linda Ronstadt, the most recent star
of the Rosemary Clooney Music Festival in Maysville.
Incidentally,
personal thanks to my colleague at The Post, Wayne Perry, who got
his hands on an advance copy of the album -- er, CD -- and sent
it to me. I have nearly worn it out.
If
one may be allowed a professional observation, Miss Midler seems
to be in excellent voice for this session, as good as I have heard
in years.
Bette
and Barry have chosen a couple of selections from an early album
of Academy Award-winning songs, including the opener, "You'll
Never Know."
Miss
Midler, always courageous, does not even shrink from pop music's
third rail, "White Christmas."
All
in all, it is a wonderfully satisfying exposition of the gifts of
Bette Midler, Barry Manilow, Linda Ronstadt and many top-notch musicians,
all tipping the hat to the talent and life of Rosemary Clooney.
Perhaps
only one mild disappointment. As some of you know, Mr. Manilow was
a friend of the widow of the premier lyricist of his day, Johnny
Mercer. Ginger Mercer drew Barry's attention to one of the poems
Johnny left behind, a powerful evocation of life's twilight years.
Barry put
music to it worthy of the giants of the classical pop era and the
result was a poignant masterpiece, "When October Goes."
Barry
took the song to Rosemary and I believe it one of the three best
recordings of her later period. It would have been a great salute
to that remarkable extension of her career into her mature years.
But that is a wish, not a criticism.
Go
out and buy it. That's what I'm going to do, to send to friends.
Then sit down and listen with someone you love. That's what I am
doing right now.
Nick
Clooney writes for The Post every Monday, Wednesday and Friday.
People
By: Chuck Arnold
October 13, 2003
It's
hard to imagine anyone who would have been better for this Rosemary
Clooney tribute than the Divine Miss M. With just the right combination
of swing and sass, Midler perfectly captures the spirit of the pop-
jazz chanteuse, who rose to fame in the '50s and died at 74 last
year. The disc reunites Midler with Barry Manilow, who produced
her first two albums. Manilow coproduced this CD, plus he sings
and plays piano on a playful, punchy version of "On a Slow
Boat to China." Midler seems to be having a blast with these
faithful yet fresh renditions, making Clooney classics like 1951's
"Come on-a My House" inviting once again.
CD
REVIEW: Cincinatti Post
Midler delivers the songs of 'girl singer' pal Clooney
By Rick Bird
Post staff reporter
Bette
Midler, "Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook"
The
Divine Miss M is out with the first tribute album to Rosemary Clooney
since Clooney's death last year, and while the effort is not totally
divine it does have plenty of pleasing moments.
The
effort was arranged and produced by Barry Manilow, who produced
Midler's earliest albums and also performed with Clooney on some
projects in the '90s.
Manilow
sings with Midler on a great campy version of "Slow Boat to
China," reprising the Clooney-Bing Crosby performance from
1958.
But
Manilow's arrangments are a little too slick and over-the-top at
times, frequently coming off achingly sweet and lush.
To
Midler's credit, she plays it fairly straight as a pop singer, staying
true to Clooney's intimate delivery as Midler mostly resists the
effort to resort to her cabaret camp roots. She does a tremendous
job on "Hey There," "Tenderly" and "White
Christmas."
She
rightfully gets back into hamming it up on "Mambo Italiano."
The
highlight of the album is Midler's thoroughly delightful duet with
Linda Ronstadt on "Sisters," which Rosemary originally
sang with her sister Betty for the 1954 movie "White Christmas."
The
nagging problem for some longtime Clooney fans may be the selection
of material, which stops short of being the "Rosemary Clooney
Songbook."
The
emphasis is on Clooney's '50s hits. So it doesn't include the exquisite
arrangements she did later with Nelson Riddle, nor does it draw
from Clooney's seminal Concord jazz recordings in the '70s.
Indeed,
Clooney herself was known to grow to detest some of those '50s hits,
which she felt were fluff.
She
hardly ever performed "Come On-a My House" or "Mambo
Italiano" in the last half of her career.
And
Midler's inclusion of the twangy "This Ole House" is similarly
puzzling.
Despite
the quibbles, Midler delivers a heartfelt Clooney tribute with her
voice as spirited and charismatic as ever and shows she is indeed
a card-carrying member of Rosemary's "girl singer" club.
CD
Review: U-Bulletin
Bette
Midler, "Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook"
' -- Rosemary Clooney is one of America's beloved singers. With
Midler on vocals and Barry Manilow working behind the scenes, the
pair release a heartfelt tribute to the late songstress. Manilow
does "A Slow Boat to China," ' and Linda Ronstadt prepares
a fun duet with Midler on "Sisters."
SEATTLE
POST-INTELLIGENCER
By Gene Stout The
late Rosemary Clooney -- yep, George Clooney's aunt -- was among
the top female vocalists of the 1950s. Bette Midler pays tribute
to the warm and sometimes swinging songstress in an album that reunites
Midler with her original piano accompanist and musical director,
Barry Manilow. Together, M&M offer a sentimental look at the
Clooney era with well-orchestrated versions "This Ole House,"
"Hey There" and "Mambo Italiano," as well as
pop classics "Tenderly," "Come on-a My House,"
"In the Cool, Cool, Cool of the Evening," and, of course,
"White Christmas" -- just in time for the pre-Christmas
buying season. (Gene Stout)
GRADE:
B+
Barnes
& Noble (AMG)
By William Pearl
Bette
Midler and Barry Manilow -- contemporary musical legends touched
by the personal warmth and grand vocal artistry of the late Rosemary
Clooney -- have come together to pay homage to one of the greatest
and most beloved American singers. Although he does sing on one
of the album’s tracks (“A Slow Boat to China”), Manilow mainly sticks
to behind-the-scenes roles as producer and arranger; the spotlight
remains on Midler’s still strong, spunky, and affecting vocals.
Clooney put her stamp on some endearing and enduring material over
the years, and here Midler turns her sights on such signature numbers
as the touching ballads “Hey There,” and “Tenderly,” as well as
the humorous hits “Come On-a My House” and “Mambo Italiano.” (Linda
Ronstadt has fun dueting with Midler on “Sisters”). As heartfelt
as it is well executed, this pleasurable tribute reflects well on
Midler, Manilow, and the absent lady of the hour, Rosemary Clooney.
William Pearl
Amazon.com
By Elisabeth Vincentelli
It's nice to see Bette Midler putting her spin on an American classic
after less-than-convincing detours through adult-contemporary cheese.
This tribute focuses on Rosemary Clooney in the early to mid-1950s--so
we don't get any of the fabulous Nelson Riddle material--but it's
a fairly strong offering. It was produced and arranged by Midler's
old musical director, Barry Manilow--who actually dueted with Clooney
on a couple of songs in the 1990s and here replaces Bing Crosby
on the duet "On a Slow Boat to China." Mostly, the CD
is about hits: "Hey There" and "White Christmas"
are done in straightforward manner, while Linda Ronstadt fills in
for Rosemary's actual sister Betty on a slinky version of "Sisters."
Happily, Midler plays "Come On-A My House" down instead
of up (the old Bette would have milked its comic aspect) but the
singer lets loose on "Mambo Italiano." That's pretty much
the only time the Divine Miss M peeks out from behind Clooney's
elegant persona, and it's a delight. --Elisabeth Vincentelli
Entertainment
Weekly
By Kristina Feliciano
10-03-2003, pp 72.
Nonessential
but not to be written off entirely, thanks to some winning interpretations:
"On a Slow Boat to China" (a duet with Barry Manilow,
one of the CD's coproducers) is crisply merry, and "Tenderly"
is suffused with dusky restraint. Midler is clearly in her element
with these songs, which Clooney recorded in the '50s. But she might
have avoided novelties like "Mambo Italiano"--if you thought
its modest charm had already been exhausted, this labored rendition
could bring out your resentful side. C+
Lexington
Herald-Leader
Posted on Fri, Oct. 17, 2003
There
are moments on Songbook when it's tough to accept that Midler is
actually the one singing. A vocalist of great sensitivity who often
loses her way in tacky camp, Midler is on good behavior here. Part
of the reason, tough as it is to admit, is a reunion with Barry
Manilow as a producer. More than 30 years ago, Manilow produced
Midler's first two albums, before his own career as one of pop's
more maudlin stylists erupted. The tribute takes a few risks, as
in its placing of breezy banjo by country/bluegrass great Herb Pederson
alongside synthesized whistles on This Ole House. Tenderly, with
more expected orchestration, will please Clooney die-hards. Not
everything works. The Midler/Manilow duet on Slow Boat to China
is total corn. The swing on In the Cool, Cool, Cool of the Evening
sounds oddly stiff. Still, it's been ages since Ms. M has sounded
anywhere near this divine.
Miami Herald
Oct. 17, 2003
BY HOWARD COHEN
BETTE MIDLER
Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook (Columbia) ***
Singing standards has always been Bette Midler's
forte, unlike other aging popsters looking for career rejuvenating
(Rod Stewart, Boz Scaggs, Aaron Neville, Cyndi Lauper). Her return
to the genre is also a reunion with producer-arranger Barry Manilow
on a swinging jazz-pop tribute to the late Rosemary Clooney.
Manilow knows Midler's strengths and on this 30-minute,
refreshingly flab-free CD, he plays to these and the two team for
a playful duet of On a Slow Boat to China.
Fans of adult pop should consider this one a best
Bette.
From
Metro Weekly
Babs or Bette
Barbra Streisand falters with bland love songs,
Bette Midler bats Clooney out of the park
by Doug Rule
Published on 11/20/2003
Barbra
Streisand poses bestride a film camera in a newly released Annie
Liebowitz photo. But the noted filmmaker hasn’t made a new movie.
Instead, Streisand’s released another high-concept album, this time
one made up of songs from movies that have inspired her through
her 40 years in the biz -- and none of them her own. Too bad she
wasn’t inspired by at least one mid-tempo movie song, or one with
any real spark of energy. As it is there’s little in this mushy
mish-mash of a collection to inspire the rest of us, starting with
the highly uninspiring title -- a better moniker could have been
snagged from one of the album’s songs: "How Do You Keep the
Music Playing? "
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Streisand
answers that question by loading up an album -- her sixtieth --
with too-precise renditions of sad love songs and slow love songs
and haunting love songs. Every song is overproduced and overwrought.
Audrey Hepburn’s Holly Golightly sounded nowhere near as go-heavy
and gloppy as Streisand on "Moon River, " for example.
At another point, Streisand teeters on the brink of losing her studied
composure. In "Calling You, " she shouts in a shrill voice,
"oh can you hear me? " -- pronounced "may, "
showing that she’s learned a trick or two about modern-day pop pronunciation.
It’s an outburst that otherwise mars her best cover, taken from
the underappreciated film Baghdad Café.
Is
she really worried no one’s listening? Well, she doesn’t make it
easy. Actually, she makes it as difficult as possible. So "inspired
" was she by three of the 12 songs here that she decided to
change them, in each case adding lyrics. It’s not clear why she
did this, especially on "Calling You, " where she conscripted
composer Bob Telson to add a third verse that doesn’t add any meaning.
Did she add it so that she wouldn’t sound quite so desperate shouting
at us to listen several bars earlier?
It
shows real chutzpah that she even approached Telson, composer Andre
Previn ("More In Love With You ") and lyricist Johnny
Mercer ("Emily "), asking them to alter their work. It’s
Streisand, so of course they can’t say no. And, being Streisand,
they must have assumed her natural chutzpah would shine through
in her versions of their songs, or that she would work with her
arrangers to make these songs actually sing.
If
only. The album is a slog, uniform in tempo and feeling. Don’t read
her liner notes expecting a break from her sentimental mood. She’s
added comments about each song, written in blog-style navel-gazing,
using precious language. She recounts when her "sweet little
nine-year-old Bijon-Frise " had to be "put to sleep ";
alludes to her "little crush " on ‘50s actor Tony Franciosa;
and mentions a song from her wedding, performed "with a chamber
orchestra arrangement by my friend Marvin Hamlisch. "
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Streisand’s
album is just one of many to appear with special appeal to gays
in advance of the 2003 end-of-year holiday season. You’ll find a
better bet in Bette Midler’s take on the swinging ‘50s songs of
Rosemary Clooney, who died last year. Two of the arrangers who worked
with Streisand, Jorge Calandrelli and Rob Buchanan, also worked
with Midler. But you won’t hear any similarities as you listen to
Midler’s winning new album, which is regrettably short at just thirty
minutes.
Bette Midler sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook
Bette
sasses up Clooney standards, striding confidently through most of
them, but not all: She knocks the wind right out of the Clooney
standard "Come-on A My House " with an unthinkably inappropriate
smooth jazz programmed beat as accompaniment. Still, she outdoes
Clooney’s original on "This Ole House, " stripping the
song down to bare-bones bluegrass that adds shades of moodiness.
Midler
worked on the album with Barry Manilow, who also accompanies her
on the jaunty "On A Slow Boat to China, " subbing for
the original’s Bing Crosby. It’s a reunion for Midler and Manilow,
who started out performing together thirty years ago at a gay bathhouse,
and later on Midler’s first two albums.
On
her best behavior Midler exudes the same playful charm that Clooney
did. Nowhere is that more on display than on "Sisters, "
one of two Irving Berlin songs featured from the Clooney-starring
film White Christmas. Midler is joined by, of all people, Linda
Rondstadt, who hams it up alongside Midler, singing lines tailor-made
for dueting drag queens. "Many men have tried to split us up
but no one can, " they sing in their best put-on girly-girl
voices. It’s a hoot.
Chicago
Sun Times
Spin Control
www.suntimes.com
What
a glorious tribute indeed to one legend from another. Not a misstep
along the way, as Midler's much- matured and deeply rich vocals
faithfully take charge of some of Clooney's most beloved melodies
from 1951-58.
On
board for the sweet, sweet ride is her long-ago arranger-piano player
-- one Barry Manilow -- who co-produced and arranged the whole fabulous
shebang. Manilow also adds his vocal chops to a playful "On
a Slow Boat to China" which aptly showcases the dynamic duo's
ability to have fun with a song and with each other's artistic sensibilities.
With
an 84-piece orchestra in tow, Midler is bold and brassy on "Come
On A My House" one moment, and tugging at your heartstrings
on "You'll Never Know" the next.
There's
no stopping her by the time she gets to "Mambo Italiano,"
which plays out like the sexy, jazzed romp it was born to be. She's
a spitfire on the big band duet of "Sisters" with Linda
Rondstadt. And her sweetly intimate turn "White Christmas"
would have melted Irving Berlin's heart. Brava, Bette!
Cleveland
Free Times -
Wednesday, November 05, 2003
Retrovision :
The Divine Miss C : Bette Midler is the Rose — Clooney, that is
By Keith A. Joseph
BETTE
MIDLER DOES NOT HAVE many admirers in the almost exclusively heterosexual
domain of jazz guardians. The only reference she rates in Will Friedwald's
book Jazz Singing is as an “attitude-heavy harridan.”
That's because the jazz boys have little tolerance for camp and
will
brook no subversion in their divas. They expect them to fall into
one of
two categories: the icy, preferably blonde, purveyors of ennui and
regret (Peggy Lee) and the exquisitely tuned singing machines (Ella
Fitzgerald).
Midler
comes with no jazz pedigree. Never a band singer, never honed her
craft in smoky dives, never beaten by a hot-tempered trumpeter,
no drug busts, no breakdowns and no egomaniac driving her into the
booby hatch.
Instead,
she chose to control her own destiny. She started her career
playing one of Tevye's daughters on Broadway and went on to spread
gay euphoria at the Continental Baths. She managed to make the Andrews
Sisters' “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy” a hit all over again when the
rest of the pop world was busy “Stayin' Alive.”
Before
the iron curtain of sexual mores collapsed, all show-biz dames
were divided between red-hot mama whores and virginal girls next
door. Midler took her cue from the former. She appropriated Sophie
Tucker's vaudeville bawdiness and artfully blended it with Mae West's
ability to satirize sex without seeming smutty. Vocally, she upgraded
Lotte Lenya's defiant Teutonic growl into Americana. The secret
of the Divine Miss M's success is that under all the ersatz raunch,
you can sense the wink of a shrewd Jewish bourgeois matron performing
party tricks. She can silence a heckler with “Shut your hole, honey
— mine makes money” without alienating the Kiwanis Club contingent.
Her
career has been a roller coaster ride. In her concerts she essayed
a madcap mermaid. On screen she's played everything from a coked-out
rock diva ( The Rose ) to a loquacious Jacqueline Susann ( Isn't
She Great ). There was also a failed TV series and an attempt to
climb Mt. Everest when she played a gloriously sung but far too
likable Madame Rose in a TV version of Gypsy .
Now,
reunited with her former musical mentor, Barry Manilow, she's
focused her attention on another Rose. Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary
Clooney Songbook (Sony/Columbia) would strike a Retrovisionist as
being as perverse as Madonna doing an MTV tribute to Doris Day.
Yet where Madonna is like one of those Gypsy strippers eternally
hunting for a gimmick, Midler is an inspired artist trying to solve
a riddle: How does a professional floozy pay homage to one of the
most wholesome singing sweethearts of the 1950s? It's a dizzying
paradox. The most natural model for the gravel-voiced, Hawaiian-born
Jewish bombshell would be the world-weary, post-nervous breakdown,
zaftig Clooney of the '70s.
Midler
and Manilow, however, have focused on the novelty-singing,
ultra-sincere den mother of the Eisenhower years, when Clooney was
Bing Crosby's earnest Yuletide consort, the Mitch Miller songbird
who inspired middle-aged bridge players to mambo, and club ladies
to weep into their Jell-O molds.
The
first thing the shrewd Barry and Bette do is to undo the mayhem
of Mitch Miller, Clooney's maniacal Svengali, whom Friedwald characterizes
as “the genius par excellence of bad music.” The strategy of the
album entails achieving just the right balance of knowing when to
spin kitsch into camp, and when to revere Rosie.
Midler
transforms Clooney's hit “Come On-A My House” from a Cub Scout bribe
into early-'60s Lesley Gore bubblegum. “Mambo Italiano” is updated
into '70s disco-lite, with which one can envision Midler livening
up a gay cotillion. Clooney and Crosby's original duet of “On a
Slow Boat to China” was destroyed by Sy Oliver's overly busy and
hurried arrangement, which annihilated Frank Loesser's fine melody.
The New Age remake of the duet with Manilow is sexier and wiser;
it sounds like a seductive vamp kidding her gay best buddy with
mock flirtation. Most importantly, the song is simplified and the
melody restored.
When
it comes time for the more serious numbers, Midler reveals her
earth-mother side by rendering the plangent WWII ballad “You'll
Never Know” in the past tense and turning it into an elegy to the
recently departed Clooney. “White Christmas,” sung with the rarely
heard verse, is as open-hearted and direct as Irving Berlin intended
it.
Midler
has pulled off a sly bit of retro subversion by creating an album
warm and nostalgic enough to delight the listeners of any geezer
radio station and also, naughtily enough, to please the irony queens
at the local piano bar.
The
Philippine Star
12/19/2003
Bette the singer
SOUNDS FAMILIAR
By Baby A. Gil
Bette
Midler is such a wonderful actress people often forget she is a
great song artist, too. Think Wind Beneath My Wings from the movie
Beaches or In My Life from the soundtrack of For the Boys. Maybe
it is because she is an actress that she is able "to locate
the heart of a song and touch the heart of the listener." That
is how Barry Manilow, who played piano for Bette during their early
days, describes her in his note on the cover of the album Bette
Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook.
Produced
by Barry and Robbie Buchanan, the album has Bette paying tribute
to one of the greatest girl singers of all time. Barry continues,
"Rosemary Clooney also had this gift. When I was thinking about
who we could pay tribute to and at the same time, reinvent these
splendid songs Rosemary first introduced to the world, Bette was
my first .and only choice."
When
I was a child, long before I became aware of Ella or Billie or Peggy,
there already was Rosemary. She must have been my mother's favorite
because the radio seemed to play her songs all the time and one
of my earliest memories was hearing my Mom humming Tenderly around
the house. Then I saw White Christmas and maybe because she looked
good in that red costume, I thought she was the star of the movie
and not Bing Crosby. I came to appreciate her more as I grew up,
marveling at the sureness of her tones, that unique catch in the
throat in her singing, the warmth in her voice. I
enjoy listening to Ella and the other females in that esteemed company
but Rosie's CDs gets played more often in my room.
Bette
does not sound like Rosie but she comes close. She radiates sincerity
in every word and I get goosebumps listening to the beautiful songs
they chose to include in the album, each one rearranged and mixed
to perfection. You'll Never Know, This Ole House, On a Slow Boat
to China, a rousing number where Bette duets with Barry, Hey There,
Tenderly, Come On-A My House, Mambo Italiano, Sisters, a duet with
another girl singer I admire a lot, Linda Ronstadt, Memories of
You, In the Cool, Cool Cool of the Evening and White Christmas.
The
only gripe I have about this album is that there are only 11 cuts.
I
want more. I want more Rosie songs sang by Bette and produced by
Barry and Robbie. Where are Half as Much, Love You Didn't Do Right
By Me, Mixed Emotions or Count Your Blessings. I am sure they could
have even thought of doing something new to reinvent Rosie's Botch-a-Me.
But when you think of all the love and artistry that went into every
song, I say 11 is more than enough.
I am
sure lots of you out there will enjoy this one.
CD
Review: Washington Blade
The Washington Blade
By WINNIE MCCROY
Dec. 12, 2003
Bette
Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook
Like Bette Midler, this album is short and sassy.
Perhaps
the best of the bunch, the Divine Miss M joins Barry Manilow, everyone’s
favorite gay icon and her original piano player and musical director,
to pay tribute to one of the first divas of cabaret in “Bette Midler
Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook.” Clooney died in June 2002.
Columbia
Records’ quality compilation starts slow and steady, with Clooney’s
“You’ll Never Know,” and “This Ole House.” The set picks up when
Midler croons “On a Slow Boat to China” with her trademark harmonies.
And it positively sizzles mid-album, when she belts out very urban
renditions of “Come On-A My House,” and “Mambo Italiano.”
In
addition to her duet with Manilow on “On a Slow Boat to China,”
Midler teams up with Linda Ronstadt on “Sisters.”
The
album ends on a sweet, though not syrupy, note with “White Christmas,”
which Clooney originally recorded in 1954.
CD
Review: Out.com
Midler’s tribute, with arrangements and even some vocal help from
her old pal and bathhouse accompanist Barry Manilow, isn’t a substitute
for Clooney’s originals but will stand beside them nicely. The selections
focus on Clooney’s 1950s pop songbird era, when she recorded some
fine tunes that were worthy of her talents (“Tenderly”), some silly
novelties that weren’t (“Come on-a My House”), and some that have
become such a part of our cultural—and camp!—sensibilities that
they defy criticism (“Sisters”). Midler does pretty well with songs
from all these categories. Her performance of “Tenderly” is outstanding—passionate
and heartfelt—and she’s appropriately torchy on “Memories of You”
but is not quite as warm as Clooney on another great ballad, “You’ll
Never Know.” She’s fine on the novelties “Come on-a My House” and
“Mambo Italiano,” although we didn’t really need to hear those songs
again; much more fun are her rollicking rendition of the pseudogospel
“This Ole House” and her humorous banter with Manilow on the swinging
“Slow Boat to China,” a highlight of the disc. Of course, no Clooney
homage would be complete without tunes from the movie White Christmas,
and Midler’s excellent versions of “Sisters” with Linda Ronstadt
and the title carol, including its oft-deleted verse, will remind
fans why they loved the flick in the first place and may inspire
the uninitiated to check out Rosie and Bing this holiday season.
And if this disc inspires listeners to pick up some Clooney recordings,
both the pop stuff from the ’50s and her later work as a gifted
jazz interpreter, so much the better—you Bette! Trudy
Ring
CD
Review: Memphis Commercial Appeal
BETTE
MIDLER SINGS THE ROSEMARY CLOONEY SONGBOOK
Even
though numerous record companies are re-releasing Clooney's songs,
Midler's efforts and apparent understanding of the "popular"
songs Clooney made famous in the 1950s bring an energy to what might
have been thrown away as dated in the rush to applaud and appreciate
the late singer for the jazz that made her popular in the late 20th
century. Songs that saw brief shining moments are recreated with
bright arrangements and a sense of fun that makes "Mambo Italiano,"
"This Ole House," and "Come On-A My House,"
perfectly palatable to people who pooh-poohed and put-down their
parents' generation and the singers who sang for them.
Bette
Midler, the divine Miss M, continues to show us what a well-trained
voice and slick professionalism can accomplish. If the accent needs
to be sharp, it is. If the tone is country, then her voice carries
just enough country to pull it off. And if a nudge and a wink are
required, she pulls it off. Best of all, Midler sounds like she
is having fun doing it.
And
the pair of songs lifted from the film "White Christmas,"
including title song and the duet "Sisters," have new
arrangements. Adding Linda Ronstadt to the duet was an inspired
choice as their voices mesh while adding excellent shading to the
notes. - LARRY ROBERTS
Carl
F Gauze
Ink19.com
Here's
a quick gift idea for those relatives who don't wear black exclusively
or have fewer than five piercings. Many of you know that Rosemary
Clooney was one of the great voices of the mid-20th century, and
mastered most of the post-war styles from Broadway to Country to
Lounge. One of the great voices of the late-20th century, Bette
Midler, teams with Barry Manilow and an enormous orchestra to perform
some of Clooney's best songs. The combination of Midler's vocals
and Manilow's piano playing place these covers in beautiful, lush
arrangements, while preserving most of the original impact of Clooney's
styling. Every song is a stunner, even if you're not in tune with
this retro vocal styling. Pour yourself a Sapphire Martini and drop
this in the player. You'll groove to the Broadway sounds of "You'll
Never Know" or the fakey pastiche of "Mambo Italian,"
or pretend you're at the classiest Hoedown east of 6th avenue with
country standard "This Ole House."
These
are standards, or very close, written by Irving Berlin and Hoagie
Carmichael and a handful of lesser know but vitally significant
American song writers. Your parents, and theirs as well, listened
to this sound, and there's nothing short of global warming or the
RIAA that will keep your great grandchildren from buying this record
when they reach "that certain age." Yeah, you'd rather
be caught voting Republican than buying anything with Manilow on
it, but it's for Mom. Secretly, you'll love it too, and drop it
in the music rotation for that classy New Year's party you've always
wanted.
CD
Review: From Malaysia!
Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook
Artist: Bette Midler
(Columbia/Sony)
Reviewer: Goh Ee Koon
THIS
album is all about nostalgia as the irrepressible Bette Midler ropes
in her old piano accompanist Barry Manilow (they worked the New
York circuit together in the early day of their careers) and pays
tribute to one of their musical heroes.
The
dominant style of this album is quite different from that of the
girl-next-door vibe exuded by the late singer. The orchestrations
are downright opulent, and Midler and Manilow (who co-produces this
album) offer a robust set that suits Midler’s powerful voice. One
of the strongest aspects of this album is Midler’s style, which
is warm, big-hearted and full of life. She brings a charming earthiness
to most of the songs.
The
album is gives us an interesting insight into Midler’s and Manilow’s
comfortable relationship, which is apparently still thriving after
all these years (the banter in On a Slow Boat to China bears testament
to this). Some hip shaking occurs in the robust Mambo Italiano as
well as Sisters, on which Midler duets with Linda Ronstadt. Their
voices play off admirably against each other and the song comes
off as an elegant remake.
The
best songs, though are ones Midler tackles alone. Great examples
of these include You’ll Never Know, Hey There and a sure-voiced
Tenderly. Nice for a foot-tapping evening, this.
JazzTimes
by Christopher Loudon
Artist: Midler, Bette
Title of CD: Sings the Rosemary Clooney Songbook
Record Label: Sony
It's
taken far too long for someone to get around to paying tribute to
Rosemary Clooney. Surprisingly (in a good way), that someone turned
out to be Bette Midler. Safely sidestepping anything that might
smack of jazz, the Divine Miss M. stays focused on the mid-'50s
hitmaker Clooney throughout Bette Midler Sings the Rosemary Clooney
Songbook (Columbia). Fortunately, several of Clooney's signature
tunes-"Hey There," "Tenderly," "You'll
Never Know," "In the Cool, Cool, Cool of the Evening"-also
happen to be terrific songs. Reuniting with former accompanist Barry
Manilow (who, literally he claims, dreamed up the idea and coproduced
the album with Robbie Buchanan) has done Midler a world of good.
In recent interviews she's conceded that for once she abandoned
her control freakishness and let Manilow run the show. Wise decision.
Gone is all the scenery-chewing, Streisandesque grandiosity. In
its place is a refreshingly muted Midler who comes remarkably close
to approximating Clooney's distinctive phrasing and inimitable sincerity.
We'll forgive her getting overly rambunctious (sounding suddenly
like Bette 'N the Hood) on the goofy "Mambo Italiano,"
especially since her "Memories of You" is so softly reverential
and her sugary duet with Linda Ronstadt on "Sisters" is
so relentlessly adorable.
|