Neil Simon Wrote Screenplay For Whoopi & Bette Midler




Mister D: I’d like to thank Jeff Dagley for turning me on to this.

The following is a guest blog by Music Reference Specialist Morgan Davis.

Actress, comedian, author, and media personality Whoopi Goldberg visited the Library of Congress on Friday, May 10, to discuss her new autobiography, “Bits and Pieces: My Mother, My Brother, and Me.” Before her public conversation with Dr. Carla Hayden, Librarian of Congress, Goldberg stopped by the Library’s Whittall Pavilion to view performing arts collections.

Whoopi Goldberg’s rich and varied career inspired Music Division reference specialists Morgan Davis and Paul Sommerfeld to draw on the Music Division’s equally diverse collections while preparing a collection display for her. In a nod to Goldberg’s beloved role on “Star Trek: The Next Generation, ” the two copyright deposits for the theme to the original “Star Trek ”series were on display. The two deposits were submitted a month apart in 1966, with the second deposit including lyrics never intended to be performed. See a previous blog post, “Star Trek: Two Versions of the Opening Theme,” for more of the story.

Next, Goldberg saw published and unpublished copyright deposits by Gertrude “Ma” Rainey, who Goldberg portrayed in the 2003 Broadway revival of August Wilson’s “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom.” “See See Rider,” selected for inclusion into the National Recording Registry in 2004, and “Prove it on Me,” Rainey’s bold affirmation of her bisexuality. Continuing to draw on inspirations from Goldberg, featured next in the display were holograph manuscript arrangements from the Pearl Bailey Papers. The songs specially selected for Goldberg from the Bailey collection were “Don’t Sit on my Bed” and “Saturday Night Fish Fry,” arranged by the jazz legend Benny Carter. Both songs were performed by the great comedienne Jackie “Moms” Mabley, who Goldberg portrayed in her one-woman show in the early 1980s, performed in a duet with Pearl Bailey. Carter took special care to write vamps into the music to ensure Mabley and Bailey had room to insert their beloved, often improvised comic hijinks. In 2013, Goldberg produced and directed the documentary “Whoopi Goldberg Presents Moms Mabley,” a close look at the life of the trailblazing Mabley who paved the way for comediennes such as Goldberg to claim space in the once decidedly monochromatic and male-dominated profession. Goldberg was nominated for a primetime Emmy for the Mabley tribute.

Author and actress Whoopi Goldberg looks over a special collections display in the Whittall Pavilion on May 10, 2024. Dr. Carla Hayden, Librarian of Congress, stands in the background. Photo by Shawn Miller/Library of Congress. Note: Privacy and publicity rights for individuals depicted may apply.
Moving into the realm of works for the stage, the specialists showed a published score of Georges Bizet’s “Carmen” with lyric changes for “Carmen Jones”—the all-African-American stage adaptation of Carmen, later turned motion picture film starring Dorothy Dandridge and Harry Belafonte—superimposed over the original libretto in Oscar Hammerstein II’s hand. Hammerstein’s score was opened to the frequently covered “Beat Out Dat Rhythm on a Drum,” to which Goldberg hummed while observing the one-of-a-kind gem from the collection.

Because Goldberg appeared in the 1997 film “Cinderella,” Music Division staff couldn’t resist showing her music and lyric sketches to Rodgers and Hammerstein’s “Do I Love You Because You’re Beautiful?,” which Goldberg performs in the film. Tracing the sketches reveals the many iterations of wordplay Hammerstein underwent before finding just the right reasons.

Goldberg was amazed to see a typescript draft from the Neil Simon Papers of an unrealized film scene titled “The Merry Widows.” On the cover, handwritten in permanent marker, is the additional annotation “For Whoopi Goldberg and Bette Midler.” Goldberg exclaimed that she had never heard of nor seen the script, in which two women (played by Goldberg and Midler) are made widows after their husbands both end up dead in a botched robbery. The script includes an extended scene in which one wife confronts the other. But Simon left the script unfinished, making us wonder what might have been.


Author and actress Whoopi Goldberg looks over a special collections display in the Whittall Pavilion on May 10, 2024. Photo by Shawn Miller/Library of Congress. Note: Privacy and publicity rights for individuals depicted may apply.

The Simon Papers contain many drafts and script fragments, such as “The Merry Widows.” These fragments open new windows into his creative process and demonstrate the sheer breadth and depth of ideas that Simon generated. Moreover, they offer untapped potential for new projects, revivals, and research opportunities within several of the Music Division’s one-of-a-kind collections.

Learn more about the Music Division’s collections and contact us through Ask a Librarian to plan your research.

Share A little Divinity

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.